How the Drug War Destroyed Over $11 Trillion in Wealth, in Addition to Costing Us $5.3 Trillion
from
The Bengal Bite
May 27, 2021
No items found.
In last week's Bengal Bite, we found the Lost $5.3 Trillion U.S. Sovereign Wealth Fund by looking at the massive costs of the drug war at just the federal level. We looked at a pretty direct question: how much did it cost, and what could have happened if we’d taken the money spent and redirected it elsewhere?
This week we look at a more indirect cost, but one just as real: how much less did people that were caught up in the drug war earn as a result of their arrest, conviction, etc.? How much economic value was lost by society as a result of drug enforcement - as a result of the almost 33 million marijuana-related drug arrests (only a fraction of the 88 million drug arrests) since 1971?
In drug offenses, recidivism has a rate of around 70%, so the total amount of cannabis drug war arrests we estimate affected about 23.7 million individual people. We tried to estimate for all of those arrested, and not just those convicted and/or imprisoned. Based on some quick research and napkin math, we ballparked that on average someone arrested in the drug war lost about $250,000 in lifetime earnings, or $7000 per year for an estimated 30-year lifespan post-arrest or prison.
The Brennan Center for Justice, a liberal think tank, actually estimates almost a half-million in lifetime earnings loss for those imprisoned, or about $13,000 per year over our 30-year estimate, with just about $100,000 lost for those convicted. Our math likely underestimated some factors that the Brennan Center is more familiar with, so we averaged Brennan’s $484,000 estimate with our $250,000 estimate to arrive at $367,000 in lifetime wages loss. Multiplied by 23.7 million drug war arrests, that’s over $8.7 trillion in lost earnings. $8.7 trillion that never trickled down through communities, never built businesses or livelihoods.
Unfortunately, it gets worse: let’s say that these folks saved 10% of the wages they would have earned and put them away in an index fund compounding at 8% (the S&P return was roughly 11% since 1971). By the time we arrive at today, the loss of those wages means the loss by those 23.7 million people to on average build $113,000 in wealth each - about $2.7 trillion in lost wealth, likely much of it concentrated in minority communities. The loss of over $11 trillion in wages and wealth is over double the loss of $5.3 trillion in pointless federal spending - and that’s before you even think of the human costs like missed birthdays and funerals.
There may be room for debate on what the right way to address drug issues is, but it seems to us that there shouldn’t be much debate on what the wrong way was and in many places still is.
As bad as the “War on Drugs” has been, it’s actually been worse than most people realize. In fact, the drug war is an example of the worst kind of public policy mistake: one that does not accomplish its stated goals causes significant and lasting social harm (millions of lives destroyed), costs the country massive amounts of money, and prevents taxpayers from seeing the benefits of that money directed more productively elsewhere.